All posts

Pen Pals #2: Well, That Didn't Take Long

A loose cap, a broken clip, and one very unfortunate pair of pants. My Pilot Metropolitan’s first real pocket test did not go well.

Hand-drawn illustration of a bronze fountain pen with its cap and clip detached, spilled ink, and ink-stained brown pants.

I ended my first Pen Pals post with a simple hope:

Hopefully, I can manage not to lose it.

Well, I didn’t lose the pen.

Just its cap. And, for a little while, my faith in the whole thing.

An unfortunate amount of ink

At some point today, the cap came off my Pilot Metropolitan while it was in my pocket. I didn’t notice until the pen had deposited a fairly impressive amount of black ink onto my pants.

A large black ink stain on the pocket area of a pair of brown pants.

Not quite the writing sample I had in mind.

I eventually found the cap in my car seat. That was a relief, until the clip promptly fell off too.

So now I had a pen that had leaked all over my pants, a cap I couldn’t trust to stay on, and a pocket clip that was no longer attached to anything.

Wonderful.

I superglued the clip back into place. It looks serviceable enough, but I can’t say the same for my confidence in it.

The Metropolitan's gold cap beside its detached clip.

The cap and clip, before my less-than-elegant repair.

One more detail I discovered afterward: the pen was completely empty. Not just a little ink lost to the incident. Every last drop.

Apparently, my pants are now a Pilot ink cartridge. Unfortunately, they’re considerably less reusable.

The part that bothers me

The frustrating thing is that I actually like the Metropolitan. It writes nicely, has a reassuring bit of weight, and feels like a much more expensive pen than it is.

But in my last post, I spent an unreasonable amount of time talking about pocket clips. I’d lost enough Zebra pens to know that a good writer isn’t particularly useful if it can’t stay put. That’s part of why I chose the Metropolitan in the first place.

As it turns out, keeping the entire pen attached to your pocket isn’t much help if the cap can come off while you’re wearing it.

Maybe I got unlucky. Maybe this particular cap wasn’t as secure as it should have been. I’m not prepared to condemn every Metropolitan on the basis of one incident.

I am, however, pretty reluctant to conduct the same experiment with another pair of pants.

Back to Lamy

I’ve already ordered a Lamy Vista with a left-handed nib.

The Vista is essentially a transparent Safari, which brings me almost all the way back to the fountain pen I loved in college. It has that distinctive oversized wire clip, and I’m curious to see how the left-handed nib compares with Pilot’s.

Of course, the Vista also uses a snap cap. I’m not pretending that switching brands magically solves the problem. I’ll be paying a lot more attention to how firmly that cap stays in place before trusting it in a pocket.

Apparently, after all that research into nibs, ink, paper, and pen bodies, the most important feature of my everyday fountain pen might be the part that keeps it closed.

I still want a fountain pen I can carry everywhere. I’d just prefer that the ink stay inside it.